Skip to Content Skip to Navigation Skip to Dashboard Skip to Search

Casey Key Homes for Sale

Casey Key is a private beach-lined expanse with exquisite waterfront homes located directly on the Gulf of Mexico and Intracoastal Waterway. While boasting some of the most internationally distinguished properties, Casey Key has preserved the ambiance of a secluded paradise. 

The island stretches only eight miles long and the majority of the land is less than 300 yards wide, resulting in enviable “Gulf-to-bay” properties showcasing infinite water views. This gives homeowners the best of both worlds: crystalline beaches on Gulf waters across from private docks on the bay.

Read More About Casey Key


Search Casey Key Real Estate Listings

Map View New Construction Save this Search
Sort listings by:New Listings First
Photo of Listing #O6025751

4024 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS, FL

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 4 Beds
  • 5 Baths
  • 4,081 SQFT
  • 2 DOM
View Details & More Photos Save

4024 Casey Key Rd, Nokomis, Fl 34275 Casey Key Estate With Unparalleled Location, True Florida Gem Offering A Secluded Utopia While Being Close To Culture Of Venice And Sarasota Areas. 180° Views Of Little Sarasota Bay And A Quiet Deeded Gulf Beac...

Photo of Listing #N6121180

1912 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS, FL

If You Ever Imagined Building Your Dream Home Overlooking The Turquoise Blue Waters Of The Gulf Of Mexico, Relaxing On Your Own Private Beach And Taking The Boat Out For An Evening Sunset, Your Opportunity Is Here. This Gulf-to-bay Homesite Is Sit...

4005 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS, FL

Prime Buildable Lot With Magnificent Unobstructed Gulf Views, This Vacant Lot Is Located On An 8-mile Barrier Island Of Casey Key. Ready To Build Your Tropical Escape And Never Miss A Glowing Sunset Over The Gulf Of Mexico. This Prime Lot Is Almos...

1312 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS, FL

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 6 Beds
  • 8 Baths
  • 11.8k SQFT
  • 19 DOM
View Details & More Photos Save

The Barrier Island And Enclave Known As Casey Key Offers Some Of The Most Exquisite Residences Along The Gulf Coast. Included In This Portfolio Of Majestic Gems Includes Tweenwater, An Estate Aptly Named As It Rests Between Sarasota’s Blackburn Ba...

412 South Casey Key, NOKOMIS, FL

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 6 Beds
  • 5 Baths
  • 3,983 SQFT
  • 23 DOM
View Details & More Photos Save

This Exceptional Waterfront Setting Is Primed To Gift You And Yours Cherished Privacy, A Panorama Of Picturesque Views, And The "sheer" Magic That Occurs Each Day When A Gorgeous Sunset On The Gulf Of Mexico Is Your Most Prominent Neighbor. Be Ass...

Photo of Listing #A4527233

513 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS, FL

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 2,516 SQFT
  • 51 DOM
View Details & More Photos Save

Welcome To Beautiful Casey Key Where This Gulf-front Beach House Illuminates Captivating Sunsets And Expansive Unobstructed Views Of The Gulf Of Mexico. Beachy, Charming And Perfectly Situated On 0.94 Of An Acre With 84 Feet Of Waterfront And Is A...

2501 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS, FL

Imagine The Ultimate Waterfront Residence, Gulf To Bay, On One Of Southwest Florida's Most Desirable Barrier Islands And A Coveted Address That Is Casey Key. Rarely Available, This Homesite Is Situated On 100 Feet Of A Private, Seawall-protected B...

3999 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS, FL

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 954 SQFT
  • 71 DOM
View Details & More Photos Save

Welcome To Casey Key, One Of The Most Exclusive Barrier Islands On The Florida Gulf Coast. This Property Offers A Vintage "old Florida" Cottage On Just Over A Half An Acre. Enjoy Endless Warm Gulf Breezes By Day And Magnificent Sunsets In The Even...

1210 Casey Key Road, NOKOMIS, FL

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 5 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 2,784 SQFT
  • 114 DOM
View Details & More Photos Save

One Or More Photo(s) Has Been Virtually Staged. It's Always All About The Location! Casey Key Is A Very Private Narrow Barrier Island Located Just North Of Venice Fl And South Of Siesta Key; It Separates The Intracostal Waterway And The Gulf Of Me...

1544 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY, FL

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 6 Beds
  • 8 Baths
  • 6,997 SQFT
  • 133 DOM
View Details & More Photos Save

The Narrow Island Of Casey Key Is One Of Sarasota's Hidden Gems, An Isolated And Exclusive Enclave Just Off The Sleepy Mainland Town Of Osprey. The Key Is A Spectacularly Lush Barrier Island 15 Miles South Of Sarasota Named For Captain John Charle...

476 North Casey Key Road, OSPREY, FL

Residential, Single Family Residence
  • 3 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 4,555 SQFT
  • 182 DOM
View Details & More Photos Save

Stunning Contemporary Masterpiece, Custom-designed By Award Winning Sarasota Architect Mark Sultana And Just Completed At The End Of 2021. Located On The Bayside Of Exclusive North Casey Key And Built By Sarasota’s Premier Luxury Home Builders Vo...

The Casey Key Real Estate Market

Casey Key homes for sale are incredibly diverse with everything from magnificent waterfront estates to old Florida beach houses and everything in between. The real estate market consists mainly of single-family homes including custom-designed contemporary homes and older homes with the option to remodel or expand. 

One of the most aesthetically pleasing aspects of this exclusive enclave is the diversity of architectural styles. Stroll along the quiet tree-lined streets and you’ll find homes for sale in Casey Key that boast Spanish Colonial, Greek Revival and European Minimalist influences. Many homes also feature beautiful landscaping with tropical flowers and foliage.

Luxury homes in Casey Key have all the features you could ask for and then some including inviting swimming pools, outdoor showers, private boat docks and beach access. Interiors could feature open-plan living areas, chef’s kitchens, granite countertops, wet bars, fireplaces, dual vanities and stand-alone bathtubs.

Older homes in Casey Key are great value because the price point may be lower and there may be potential for further development. Some older homes have already been remodeled with modern appliances, storm windows, and state-of-the-art HVAC systems. Others have Sarasota County zoning that allows for upgrades, extensions and additions.

Residents who own real estate in Casey Key can rest easy knowing that the majority of the island is protected as a conservation district, which prevents view-obstructing high-rises and distasteful development. Ground elevations are also notably higher than most barrier islands. Canopies of lush tropical trees shade the majority of the roads and sea oats and mangroves house exotic birds and wildlife; all protected to promise continued abundance for the times to come.

Luxury and Waterfront Homes for Sale

The following Casey Key luxury and waterfront homes for sale represent all of the active real estate listings on the key. It includes all of the active single family homes available on the multiple listing service (MLS). These listings are automatically updated to keep the information current. We would be pleased to schedule a private showing for you. Call Gulf Shores Realty today at 941-488-6644 to schedule your private showing.

The Casey Key Lifestyle

Casey Key is all about the beach lifestyle. Whether you enjoy Gulf or Bay views from the balcony of your 10-million-dollar home or prefer to sit on a public beach with your toes in the warm sand, you’ll find this slice of paradise a perfect fit. Casey Key has both public and private beaches to enjoy. At the northern end of the island there is a small park with a boat launch.

Outdoor enthusiasts will love how walkable Casey Key is. You can step out your door and stroll along peaceful streets lined with tropical greenery. Cyclists can head to the mainland to get onto The Legacy Trail. This car-free paved trail runs for 10.7 miles with spectacular views at every turn. There are also several beautiful parks in and around Nokomis and Osprey.

Casey Key is mainly residential, so you won’t find chain restaurants or stores here. However, there are plenty of dining and shopping options across the Intracoastal Waterway. Nokomis has a number of enticing waterfront restaurants and tiki bars. Popular spots include the Casey Key Fish House, Mama Leone’s Italian and Pop’s Sunset Grill.

Casey Key Image Gallery

Gulf Shores Realty: 608640009 Gulf Shores Realty: 174519368

Location and Directions

Casey Key is easily accessed by crossing one of two bridges; the Blackburn Point Rd swing bridge in Osprey or the Albee Road drawbridge in Nokomis. 

In Osprey FL, proceed west from the intersection of U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail) and Blackburn Point Rd. Proceed west to just past the historic swing bridge to Casey Key Rd. 

In Nokomis FL, proceed west from the intersection of U.S. 41 (Tamiami Trail) and Albee Road until you cross over the Albee Road drawbridge. Turn on Casey Key Road.

Call us today at 941-488-6644

^ Back to: Casey Key Homes

All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

Listing data comes from My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS.

Listing information last updated on May 18th, 2022 at 8:33am EDT.